Problem 50
Medium Second-Order Classification

Find the integral surface of tan x· p + y q = z, p = (∂…

Find the integral surface of \[ \tan x\cdot p + y\,q = z, \qquad p = \frac{\partial z}{\partial x},\quad q = \frac{\partial z}{\partial y}, \] that passes through the curve $y=x$, $z=x^3$.

Explanation of Method

Because the initial data does not let $\Phi$ be solved for in closed elementary form, the resulting integral surface is naturally expressed in parametric form, with the parameter $t$ identifying the point of the initial curve each characteristic passes through.

Step 1 · Characteristic equations and first integrals

\[ \frac{dx}{\tan x} = \frac{dy}{y} = \frac{dz}{z}. \tag{1} \] From the last two ratios: $z/y=c_1$. \tag{I} From the first two: $\cot x\,dx=dy/y \Rightarrow y/\sin x=c_2$. \tag{II}

Step 2 · General solution

\[ z = y\,\Phi\!\left(\frac{y}{\sin x}\right). \tag{$*$} \]

Step 3 · Apply the initial condition (parametrically)

On $y=x$, $z=x^3$, parametrise by $t=x$, so along the characteristic through the initial point $t$: $c_1=z/y=t^2$ and $c_2=y/\sin x=t/\sin t$. Eliminating $t$ between $z=yc_1$ and $c_2=y/\sin x$ gives the surface implicitly in terms of the parameter $t$: \[ z = y t^2, \qquad y\sin t = t\sin x. \]


Verification

Setting $t=x$ recovers $y=x$ (from $y\sin x=x\sin x$) and then $z=yx^2=x^3$. $\checkmark$
Checking $c_1=z/y$ and $c_2=y/\sin x$ against $PF_x+QF_y+RF_z=0$ with $P=\tan x$, $Q=y$, $R=z$ confirms both are first integrals: \[ \tan x\cdot0+y\!\left(-\frac{z}{y^2}\right)+z\cdot\frac1y = 0, \qquad \tan x\!\left(-\frac{y\cos x}{\sin^2x}\right)+\frac{y}{\sin x} = 0. \checkmark \] Differentiating $z=y\Phi(y/\sin x)$ and substituting into $\tan x\cdot p+yq$ confirms it collapses to $y\Phi=z$. $\checkmark$

Result

The integral surface is given parametrically by:

\[ \boxed{z = y t^2, \qquad y\sin t = t\sin x} \] where $t$ is a parameter (the value of $x$ on the initial curve for each characteristic).