Problem 133
Medium Numerical and Functional Series

Test the absolute and conditional convergence

Test the absolute and conditional convergence of the series (for fixed $x$ with $0<x<\pi$): $$ \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} \frac{\sin(nx)}{n^a}. $$

Explanation of Method

Since $0<x<\pi$ ensures $\sin(x/2)\ne0$, the classical closed-form identity for $\sum\sin(n\theta)$ gives a uniform bound $1/\sin(x/2)$ on the partial sums, independent of $N$. This is precisely the hypothesis Dirichlet's test needs, so pairing with the monotone decrease of $n^{-a}$ for $a>0$ secures convergence throughout, with the sharper threshold $a>1$ needed for absolute convergence.

  1. Derive the closed-form bound on partial sums of $\sin(nx)$.
  2. Apply Dirichlet's test for $a>0$.
  3. Determine the absolute-convergence threshold at $a=1$.

Step 1 · Bound the partial sums

$$ \sum_{n=1}^N\sin(nx) = \frac{\sin\left(\frac{Nx}2\right)\sin\left(\frac{(N+1)x}2\right)}{\sin(x/2)}, \qquad \left|\sum_{n=1}^N\sin(nx)\right|\le\frac1{|\sin(x/2)|}. $$

Since $0<x<\pi$ gives $0<x/2<\pi/2$, we have $\sin(x/2)>0$, so this bound is finite and independent of $N$.

Step 2 · Apply Dirichlet's test

For $a>0$, $n^{-a}\downarrow0$, and Step 1 gives bounded partial sums, so by Dirichlet's test the series converges for every $a>0$.

Step 3 · Absolute convergence threshold

Since $x$ is a fixed constant in $(0,\pi)$ not a rational multiple of $\pi$ in general, $|\sin(nx)|$ stays bounded away from $0$ on a positive-density subsequence of $n$, so $\sum|\sin(nx)|/n^a$ compares with $\sum1/n^a$: convergent iff $a>1$. So absolutely convergent for $a>1$, conditionally convergent for $0<a\le1$; for $a\le0$, terms $\sin(nx)/n^a$ don't tend to $0$ (bounded away from zero infinitely often since $x\ne k\pi$), so the series diverges.


Summary Table

Range of $a$Conclusion
$a>1$Absolutely convergent
$0<a\le1$Conditionally convergent
$a\le0$Diverges

Additional Notes

Result

Absolutely convergent for $a>1$; conditionally convergent for $0<a\le1$:

$$ \sum_{n=1}^{\infty} \frac{\sin(nx)}{n^a} \begin{cases} \text{absolutely convergent}, & a>1 \\ \text{conditionally convergent}, & 0<a\le1 \\ \text{diverges}, & a\le0, \end{cases} \qquad 0<x<\pi. $$