Problem 211
Easy Planes

What condition must hold among A_i,B_i,C_i,D_i for the three…

What condition must hold among $A_i,B_i,C_i,D_i$ for the three planes $A_ix+B_iy+C_iz+D_i=0$ ($i=1,2,3$) to pass through a common point?

Explanation of Method

The condition on the coefficients for three planes to have a common point.

Step 1: Condition (Kronecker–Capelli)

Let $M=(A_i\ B_i\ C_i)$ be the $3\times3$ coefficient matrix and $\widetilde M=(A_i\ B_i\ C_i\ D_i)$ the $3\times4$ augmented matrix. A common point exists iff

\[\operatorname{rank}M=\operatorname{rank}\widetilde M\]

Using $D_i$ or $-D_i$ in the last column does not change the rank.

Step 2: Cases

RanksCommon points
$\Delta=\det M\ne0$ (rank 3)exactly one point, for any $D_i$
$\operatorname{rank}M=\operatorname{rank}\widetilde M=2$a common line (pencil)
$\operatorname{rank}M=\operatorname{rank}\widetilde M=1$the three planes coincide
$\operatorname{rank}M\lt \operatorname{rank}\widetilde M$none

When $\Delta\ne0$, Cramer's rule gives the point: \[x_0=\frac{\Delta_x}{\Delta},\quad y_0=\frac{\Delta_y}{\Delta},\quad z_0=\frac{\Delta_z}{\Delta},\] where $\Delta_x,\Delta_y,\Delta_z$ are obtained by replacing a column of $\Delta$ with $(-D_1,-D_2,-D_3)^T$.

When $\Delta=0$ and $\operatorname{rank}M=2$, consistency requires the $3\times3$ minors of $\widetilde M$ containing the $D$-column to vanish. In fact one of them suffices: any minor formed with two independent columns of $M$.


Result

\[\boxed{\,\operatorname{rank}M=\operatorname{rank}\widetilde M\,}\]