Problem 586
Hard Tangents, Normals, and Asymptotes

Find the locus of the feet of the perpendiculars dropped

Find the locus of the feet of the perpendiculars dropped from the origin onto the tangents of the curve $x=a(\cos t+t\sin t),\ y=a(\sin t-t\cos t)$ (the involute of a circle of radius $a$).

Explanation of Method

A rotation matrix in disguise: the tangent and its perpendicular from the origin form an orthogonal pair.

Step 1: Velocities

\[ \dot x = a(-\sin t+\sin t+t\cos t) = at\cos t, \qquad \dot y = a(\cos t-\cos t+t\sin t) = at\sin t. \tag{1} \]

Step 2: The tangent line

The slope is $\dot y/\dot x=\tan t$. Writing the tangent through $T=\bigl(a(\cos t+t\sin t),\,a(\sin t-t\cos t)\bigr)$ with this slope and multiplying by $\cos t$, the $-a\sin t\cos t$ terms cancel and $y_0\cos t-x_0\sin t=-at$ (since $\cos^2t+\sin^2t=1$), leaving

\[ x\sin t - y\cos t = at. \tag{2} \]

Step 3: The perpendicular from the origin

Slope $-\cot t$, through the origin: \[x\cos t + y\sin t = 0. \tag{3}\]

Step 4: The foot $M$

Equations (2)–(3) form an orthogonal (rotation-type) linear system in $x,y$. Multiplying (2) by $\sin t$ and (3) by $\cos t$ and adding eliminates $y$; multiplying (2) by $\cos t$ and (3) by $\sin t$ and subtracting eliminates $x$:

\[ x_M = at\sin t, \qquad y_M = -at\cos t. \tag{4} \]

Step 5: Polar form of the locus

\[ x_M^2+y_M^2 = a^2t^2 \;\Longrightarrow\; \rho = a|t|. \tag{5} \]

From (4), $\cos\varphi=x_M/\rho=\pm\sin t$ and $\sin\varphi=y_M/\rho=\mp\cos t$ (sign matching that of $t$); for $t>0$ this gives $\cos\varphi=\sin t,\ \sin\varphi=-\cos t$, i.e.\ $\varphi=t-\dfrac\pi2$, so $t=\varphi+\dfrac\pi2$. Substituting into $\rho=at$:

\[ \rho = a\!\left(\varphi+\frac\pi2\right). \tag{6} \]

Step 6: Verification

\[a=2,\ t=0.3,1.2,2.5\text{: }\rho=at\text{ matches }\sqrt{x_M^2+y_M^2}\text{ exactly, and }\varphi=t-\pi/2\text{ to machine precision}\ \checkmark\]

\[t=-0.7\text{: }\rho=a|t|=1.4\text{ (not }at=-1.4\text{), confirming }\rho=a|t|\text{ for negative }t\text{ too}\ \checkmark\]


Result

Final answer:

\[\boxed{\,\rho = a\!\left(\varphi+\frac\pi2\right)\,}\]

an Archimedean spiral $\rho=a\psi$ in the angle $\psi=\varphi+\pi/2$ — i.e.\ the same spiral $\rho=a\psi$, just with its polar axis rotated by $\pi/2$ relative to the coordinate frame used for $x,y$.